Comparison of cms preventive maintenance regulations. Make sure there is an appropriate balance of conditional inspections, preemptive replacements, monitoring technology applications, andor runtofailure strategies based on observed asset behavior. It defines strategies where you dont need a system and strategies that require a system for data collection. Total productive maintenance tpm planned predictive maintenance pdm daily productive maintenance dpm systematically planned annual maintenance spam which of following is considered a short term maintenance strategy.
Selecting a successful maintenance strategy requires a good knowledge of equipment failure behaviour and maintenance management practices. The pros and cons of different maintenance strategies. Run to failure run to failure event failure finding failure finding conditioncondition r c m asset maintenance evolution rcm. Driven by a runtofailure maintenance strategy, a maintain production at all costs mandate, and an underutilized computer maintenance management system cmms, a complete overhaul of their approach to maintenance was needed for the refinery to reopen. Ive interviewed reliability and maintenance management experts to develop this guide focusing on maintenance technology. Preventive maintenance strategies using reliabilitycentered maintenance rcm,page 3 of 6 technique pm4 page pm23 b. This is a maintenance strategy or replacement policy, which is sometimes also called fit and forget an intentional strategy whereby no maintenance tasks are performed on an asset. Maintenance is performed only after the equipment fails. Runtofailure maintenance is sometimes called crisis maintenance or hysterical maintenance for good reason. There is always some investment hurdle to overcome in changing strategy, however such costs are typically fully recovered within 2 to. An analysis of maintenance strategies and development of a model for strategy formulation a case study gustav fredriksson hanna larsson department of product and production development division of production systems chalmers university of technology goteborg, sweden, 2012.
Sometimes referred to as fit and forget maintenance, run to failure is perhaps the most costeffective of the maintenance strategies, and one that is fairly widely. A run to failure rtf approach to maintenance consumes your budget with hidden costs that eat away profits. Run to failure maintenance should not be misconstrued as unintended failure replacement ufr which is failure from neglect or ignorance without a plan to cope. Developing a proactive preventive maintenance strategy 5 it begins and ends with data leveraging the potential of preventive maintenance begins and ends with your data. In fact, your maintenance strategy can be as important to your business results as your quality program.
Runtofailure is a maintenance strategy where maintenance is performed when equipment has failed and is designed to minimize total. This is where assets are deliberately run until they fail. Run to failure maintenance strategy run to failure rtf is the simplest type of maintenance strategy, where equipment is deliberately run until it breaks down. While on the surface it does not sound like a strategy, run to failure can be the correct maintenance decision in some circumstances. The portion of maintenance work hours that are performed at an overtime rate. Most strategies are built on one or more of four basic maintenance approaches reactive preventive predictive proactive the oldest maintenance approach is reactive, or runtofailure. Run to failure maintenance strategy automated cutting. Development of equipment maintenance strategy for critical equipment. Pdf development of equipment maintenance strategy for. Allowing assets to run to failure only exacerbates the issue, and poses potential danger. The option to run to fail is based on whether maintenance costs more than the downtime created due to simply letting the part fail. An illustration of the use of the rcm decision diagram. Through the utilization of various nondestructive testing and measuring techniques, predictive maintenance determines equipment status before a breakdown occurs. This is a maintenance strategy or replacement policy, which is sometimes also called fit and forget.
This approach is common when equipment failure doesnt significantly affect operations or productivity. For components that are at the end if their lifecycle, you simply want to get every hour of operation out of the component as you can, and you are not concerned with loss of core. When failure occurs, reactive maintenance is performed to fix the asset and return it to full operation. Moreover, nowlan and heap identified that only eleven percent. The simplest maintenance strategy is to execute runtofailure maintenance also known as run to fail. A conscious decision is made by the owner to neglect the asset, regardless of any signs of potential. With the proper maintenance strategy, the maintenance group will be able to alert the operational team of pending problems before the operational team is aware of a problem, thus ensuring capacity when the business needs it most. Preventive maintenance strategies using reliability. Rcm combines professional intuition and a rigorous statistical approach, and recognizes that different maintenance strategies apply to different facility equipment. No maintenance, including preventive maintenance, is performed on the asset up until the failure event. Run to failure as a maintenance strategy reliabilityweb.
Pfm is a comprehensive maintenance strategy emphasizing the understanding of failure mechanisms, measurement, interval optimization, task prioritization. To ensure that you have a viable maintenance strategy, first examine the scheduled maintenance activities that are currently being performed. In the maintenance and reliability world we spend much of our time thinking and planning out ways to better maintain or redesign some equipment to make it last longer or be more reliable. This type of maintenance strategy is only effective for a machinery that serves a small role in the business, or those that are not very important and necessary, and which are not very costly. Which asset maintenance strategy should you be using. A run to failure or corrective maintenance strategy only restores the function of. Its an opportunity to lower product development and production costs, improve gross margins and add to your competitive advantage. In addition, senior management within smes rarely view maintenance as a strategic issue that will translate to a signi. Given the runtofailure mentality and cuts in the federal buildings fund, its no surprise that the federal maintenance backlog is large. It is less a maintenance strategy and more an approach to overall function of the assets and surrounding elements. The maintenance strategy adoption for plant assets is crucial decision.
Run to failure maintenance is an excellent strategy when the total cost of repairing the equipment is less than the cost of performing other types of maintenance after breakdown. Apart from being the outcome of a deliberate run to failure strategy corrective maintenance is also the result of unplanned failures which were not avoided through preventive maintenance. A shelf in my study holds a collection of debris from process mistakes. This has been the dominant form of maintenance for a long time, and its costs are relatively high because of unplanned downtime, damaged machinery, and. In this strategy, assets are deliberately allowed to. For example a machine that runs continuously in a 247 production.
Why runtofail is not a good maintenance strategy for sis. Rtf is a very deliberate strategy where the item is intended to run until it fails and owners are prepared to take remedial action instantly upon failure. Pdf development of equipment maintenance strategy for critical. Also known as breakdown, run to failure maintenance. Reliability strategy and plan equipment asset management. Pdf maintenance strategies and their combine impact on. The only planned maintenance on the asset is corrective maintenance after the asset has suffered a failure. However, there are situations where a reliable solution or maintenance plan is not cost effective and the.
Are all the standard materials tools, nance action is possible. Operating costs, maintenance costs and revenues report. How do you know when it is the right time to do maintenance. Methodology development of an effective maintenance strategy for critical equipment requires a. The oldest maintenance approach is reactive, or runtofailure. These concepts will be explored further in an upcoming information bulletin.
In this strategy, assets are deliberately allowed to operate until they break down, at which point reactive maintenance is performed. Typically predictive maintenance has half the net cost as runtofailure, and pcm may be half as much again. This illustration shows the potential outcomes from investing in a specific maintenance strategy type. Run to failure maintenance is a strategy where there is no maintenance plan beyond complete replacement upon asset or component failure. In many circumstances run to failure is a great maintenance strategy. In the maintenance and reliability world we spend much of our time thinking and planning out ways to better maintain or redesign some. This is a cost we could minimize under a different maintenance strategy. Development of equipment maintenance strategy for critical. There are many negative impacts that rtf has that make its a poor maintenance strategy choice for any business. Fundamentals of asset management 3 drawing from the am knowledge base this workshop is produced by ghd inc. The portion of corrective maintenance work hours that are planned and scheduled in advance not unplanned breakdowns 85 95% % overtime.
Maintenance is a risk management practice used to maximise production and minimise loss and waste. Reassessing runtofailure mentality will help address. Cost consideration is a key factor in any developed strategy as no key can function without cost input. The simplest maintenance strategy is that of breakdown maintenance. A run to failure strategy designates a machinery to be fixed only when it breaks down. To get a better understanding of the maintenance and operating strategies you can chose and how they work, click on this link and read the article titled equipment maintenance strategy 101. What are different types of maintenance strategies. Run to failure is a maintenance strategy where maintenance is only performed when equipment has failed. An analysis of maintenance strategies and development of a. With predictive devices currently available, it is incumbent upon. Predictive maintenance is the complement of preventive maintenance. The simplest maintenance strategy is to execute run to failure maintenance also known as run to fail. Selection of proper maintenance strategy for plants assets is difficult because of its suitability, limitations and the cost.
If youve found this article helpful and would like to get your own pdf copy of. Perform maintenance, not costly repairs condition based maintenance corrects developing faults such as looseness and worn bearings before a. Cooke 2003 has indicated that the majority of smes typically adopt a runtofailure maintenance strategy, as this largely requires limited knowledge on why and how the equipment failed. A run to failure strategy can effectively be used for general area lighting, smart process instrumentation without trip functionality etc. One of the fundamentals of the probability of failure on demand pfdavg calculations in sil verification analysis, is the concept of a constant failurerate during useful life of the equipment.
686 710 590 464 584 362 109 1443 802 312 1561 1240 170 997 62 1016 1062 223 676 961 564 546 1494 716 1049 1509 599 737 1234 808 576 770 1176 514 122 840 167